• AI Grand Rounds
  • Posts
  • Beyond Animal Testing: FDA's Bold Shift to AI and Human-Relevant Methods

Beyond Animal Testing: FDA's Bold Shift to AI and Human-Relevant Methods

AI in Pathology: Faster and Accurate Diagnosis

Fellow Healthcare Champions,

Are you overwhelmed by all the fluff and hype around AI and not sure how to identify meaningful information? We get it. As busy clinicians ourselves, our newsletter, "AI Grand Rounds," is here to provide clinically relevant AI information.

No matter who you are—a healthcare provider, inventor, investor, or curious reader—we PROMISE one thing: you will always find information that is relevant, meaningful, and balanced.

Let’s join our journey to share clinically meaningful and relevant knowledge on healthcare AI.

Sincerely,

Your fellow physicians!

Table of Contents

🚨 Pulse of Innovation 🚨

Breaking news in the healthcare AI

FDA Plans Phasing Out Animal Testing with AI-Driven Modern Methods

The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) is taking a groundbreaking step to reduce reliance on animal testing in drug development, particularly for monoclonal antibodies and other therapies. The new approach focuses on human-relevant testing methods to improve drug safety, accelerate approvals, lower costs, and reduce animal use.

Key Changes & Approaches

  • New Approach Methodologies (NAMs):

    • AI-based computational models predict drug toxicity and behavior.

    • Human cell lines and organoids (lab-grown mini-organs) mimic human responses better than animal tests.

  • Use of Real-World Data:

    • The FDA will consider pre-existing human safety data from countries with comparable regulatory standards.

  • Immediate Implementation:

    • Encouraged for Investigational New Drug (IND) applications.

    • A detailed roadmap has been released to guide adoption.

Benefits of the New Approach

 More Accurate Safety Data: Human-based models reduce risks missed in animal tests.
  Faster Drug Development: Streamlined processes could speed up approvals.
  Lower Costs: Reduced animal testing may decrease R&D expenses and drug prices.
  Ethical Advancements: Fewer animals (including dogs and primates) will be used in labs.
  Global Leadership: The FDA sets new standards for modern, humane regulatory science.

Regulatory & Industry Incentives

  • Faster Reviews: Companies using strong non-animal data may get priority evaluations.

  • Pilot Program Launching Soon: Select monoclonal antibody developers can test non-animal strategies under FDA guidance.

  • Public Workshop Planned: Stakeholders will discuss implementation later this year.

Quotes from FDA Leadership

“This marks a paradigm shift in drug evaluation… By leveraging AI, human organ models, and real-world data, we can get safer treatments to patients faster while reducing animal use.”
FDA Commissioner Dr. Martin A. Makary

Next Steps

  • Collaboration with NIH, VA, and ICCVAM to validate new methods.

  • Phased policy updates based on pilot program results.

  • Long-term goal: Significantly reduce or eliminate animal testing in drug development.

This move could represent a significant change for patients, science, and animal welfare, positioning the FDA as a leader in innovative, ethical drug testing.

🧑🏼‍🔬 Bench to Bedside👨🏽‍🔬

Developments in healthcare AI research and innovations

From Dialogue to Diagnosis: Evaluating AMIE, a New Era in Medical AI

The physician–patient dialogue is a cornerstone of effective diagnosis and compassionate care. In a recent Nature publication, researchers introduce AMIE (Articulate Medical Intelligence Explorer) — a large language model purpose-built for clinical history-taking and diagnostic reasoning.

AMIE marks a significant advancement in medical AI, enabling direct patient interaction through natural, empathetic conversations. Its development leveraged a novel self-play-based learning framework, allowing the model to simulate doctor–patient dialogues and iteratively improve its performance using automated feedback. This approach enabled AMIE to scale across a wide range of specialties, clinical conditions, and global patient demographics.

In a randomized, double-blind, multi-country study involving 159 simulated clinical scenarios and 20 primary care physicians (PCPs) across Canada, the UK, and India, AMIE was benchmarked using OSCE-style text consultations. The results were striking:


• AMIE outperformed PCPs in diagnostic accuracy, including top-1 and top-3 differential diagnosis performance.
• Specialist physicians rated AMIE higher on 30 out of 32 clinical evaluation metrics; patient-actors rated it higher on 25 out of 26, including empathy, professionalism, communication, and management planning.
• While equally effective in eliciting information, AMIE demonstrated superior diagnostic reasoning and decision-making.

Despite its promise, the study acknowledges key limitations: using a text-based chat interface unfamiliar to many clinicians, limited real-world variability, and the need for deeper exploration into fairness and bias. While not yet ready for clinical deployment, AMIE provides a robust framework for the future integration of AI into diagnostic workflows.

Conclusion:
AMIE represents a milestone in the evolution of conversational medical AI. With continued refinement and ethical oversight, such systems may play a vital role in expanding access to high-quality diagnostic care and supporting clinicians in an increasingly complex healthcare landscape.

AI-Driven Transformation in Public Health: Insights from a Digital Health Leader

Speaker: Dr. Karthik Adapa

  • Regional Adviser for Digital Health, WHO South-East Asia

  • Fulbright Scholar | PhD in Health Informatics | Former IAS Officer

Key Achievements:

  • Spearheaded India’s first blockchain-based healthcare recruitment system

  • Led AI deployment at population scale to reduce insurance fraud in India

  • Architected digital health strategies for 80% of South-East Asia, impacting over 2,400 public health facilities

  • Secured over $150 million in research and health system funding

  • Former IAS officer and Fulbright Scholar with a PhD in Health Informatics

  • Adjunct Faculty at UNC Chapel Hill

He brings a unique blend of governance, academic rigor, and tech-driven innovation to transform healthcare systems globally.

Why You Should Attend:

  • Learn from a rare intersection of policy, tech, and medicine

  • Practical insights into AI’s real-world clinical deployment

  • Earn CME credits

Time/Location/Date:

  • Saturday, April 19th,, 2025 - 11:00 AM EST (8:30 PM Indian Standard Time

Bonus:

Live Q&A: “How can clinicians pivot into digital health?”

🧑🏽‍⚕️ AI in Clinic 🏥

Developments in healthcare AI research and innovations

PathAI: AI-Powered Pathology for Faster, Smarter Diagnoses

Revolutionizing Pathology with AI

PathAI is at the forefront of AI-driven pathology, aiming to enhance diagnostic accuracy and efficiency. By integrating AI into pathology workflows, it helps pathologists interpret medical images with greater precision, improving patient outcomes. The company collaborates with biopharma, labs, and clinicians to advance drug development and clinical diagnostics.

Key Offerings

PathAI’s AI-powered tools optimize pathology assessments in research and clinical settings:

PathExplore – AI-driven tumor microenvironment analysis

AIM-PD-L1 – Automated PD-L1 expression detection for immunotherapy decisions

AIM-HER2 – AI-powered HER2 scoring with heatmap visualizations for breast cancer

AISight™ – Digital pathology platform for case and image management

Recent Innovations

  • NASH/MASH AI Development – In November 2023, PathAI launched an expert advisory network to guide AI-powered diagnostics for liver disease.

  • Roche Collaboration – Partnered in February 2024 to expand AI-driven digital pathology for companion diagnostics.

Challenges & Limitations

  • Data Variability – AI accuracy depends on diverse, high-quality datasets.

  • Workflow Integration – Adapting AI to existing lab systems is complex.

  • Regulatory & Ethical Concerns – Compliance and transparency remain key hurdles.

FDA Clearance & Impact

In August 2022, PathAI’s AISight Dx platform received FDA 510(k) clearance and CE Mark, allowing its use for primary diagnosis in clinical settings—an important step toward mainstream AI adoption in pathology.

With AI-driven insights, PathAI is accelerating precision medicine, making pathology faster, more consistent, and ultimately, more effective.

🤖 Patient First, AI Second🤖

Ethical and Regulatory Landscape of Healthcare AI

News on the ethical use of AI in healthcare

The FDA is refining its regulatory approach to AI-driven medical technologies, emphasizing transparency, bias mitigation, and lifecycle management. Developers are now required to implement safeguards against "algorithmic drift," ensuring that evolving AI systems remain safe and effective. These measures aim to balance innovation with patient safety, as AI-enabled devices increasingly adapt and learn from new data[6].

At the American College of Physicians' 2025 meeting, experts highlighted the dual threats of cybersecurity breaches and ethical challenges in AI use. Recent incidents, such as ransomware attacks affecting hospitals, underscore the need for robust data protection protocols. Physicians were urged to adopt multi-factor authentication and proactive downtime planning to safeguard patient data while addressing ethical concerns like transparency in AI decision-making.

A study by Mount Sinai revealed biases in AI healthcare tools that disproportionately favor high-income patients for advanced diagnostics. This finding has prompted calls for more diverse training datasets and fairness audits to ensure equitable care delivery. Addressing algorithmic bias remains a critical focus to prevent disparities in healthcare outcomes.

The World Health Organization has partnered with TU Delft's Digital Ethics Centre to advance ethical governance of AI in healthcare. This collaboration focuses on developing frameworks prioritizing transparency, equity, and safety, ensuring that AI technologies are deployed responsibly across global health systems.

Disclaimer: This newsletter contains opinions and speculations and is based solely on public information. It should not be considered medical, business, or investment advice. This newsletter's banner and other images are created for illustrative purposes only. All brand names, logos, and trademarks are the property of their respective owners. At the time of publication of this newsletter, the author has no business relationships, affiliations, or conflicts of interest with any of the companies mentioned except as noted. ** OPINIONS ARE PERSONAL AND NOT THOSE OF ANY AFFILIATED ORGANIZATIONS!

Reply

or to participate.